California Cancer Research Program

Completed Projects

 

The following Principal Investigators have completed their research as funded by CRP. Where applicable, publications resulting from CRP funding are also included.

 

CYCLE II FINAL LAY ABSTRACTS

[CLINICAL]

Clinical

 

 

Investigator-Initiated Awards

 

Jonathan S. Berek, M.D.: Nutrient Gene Interactions in Ovarian Cancer

 

Eric J. Stanbridge, Ph.D.: Evaluation of MN/CA9 Protein Expression in ASCUS Pap Smears as a Diagnostic Biomarker of Cervical Dysplasia/Neoplasia

 

Jeffrey S. Weber, M.D., Ph.D.: HPV Heat Shock Protein Vaccine for Cervical Dysplasia

 

Petra E. Wilder-Smith, D.D.S., Ph.D.: Non-Invasive Diagnosis of Pre-Malignancy and Malignancy

 

 

 

 

Pilot and Feasibility Study Awards

 

Rowan T. Chlebowski, M.D., Ph.D.: Exercise and Androgen Ablation in Prostate Cancer

 

Laura E. Crocitto, M.D.: Screening Telomerase for Prostate Cancer Detection

 

Richard Essner, M.D.: Morphologic Changes to the Sentinel Nodes in Melanoma: A Novel Mechanism for the Development and Treatment of Metastases

 

Jean Y.J. Wang, Ph.D.: Molecular Tools to Assess the Efficacy of Cancer Therapy

 

 

 

 

New Investigator Award

 

Catherine Ley, Ph.D.: HPV Infection and Cervical Cancer Screening in Hispanics

 

Min-Ying Lydia Su, Ph.D.: Selective Thrombosis of Tumor Vessels for Cancer Therapy

 

 

 

Clinical Scientist Development Award

 

James L. Rubenstein, M.D., Ph.D.: Rituximab in the Treatment of Primary CNS Lymphoma

 

Marc A. Seltzer, M.D.: PET Imaging for Prostate Cancer

 

 

 

Small Business Collaboration Award

 

John P. Fruehauf, M.D.: Biomarker Angiogenesis Index Stratifies Metastatic Risk

 

 

                  

 

ABSTRACTS

 

Nutrient Gene Interactions in Ovarian Cancer

Jonathan S. Berek, M.D.

University of California, Los Angeles

$990,389.33 / 36 months

Ovarian Cancer

Investigator-Initiated Award

 

Ovarian cancer is a major problem because there is no effective means of early detection and about three-quarters of women have advanced stage disease when they are diagnosed.  Ovarian cancer is the fifth leading cause of death in women in the United States, and has the highest fatality to case ratio of all of the gynecologic malignancies, with nearly 24,000 cases and over 13,000 deaths expected in 2003. Although many of these cancers are responsive to chemotherapy, only 20% of women with ovarian and peritoneal cancers are alive and free of disease at five years. Therefore, effective preventative strategies and other means of disease control are being sought.   There is evidence that pregnancy, the oral contraceptive pill, and several nutrients may play a role in the reduction of ovarian and peritoneal cancer risk.   Although dietary factors have been associated with the etiology of ovarian cancer, especially dietary intake of retinoids, dairy and soy products, the relationship between fat, fiber, and other nutritional factors and the clinical progression of epithelial ovarian and peritoneal cancers as well as the molecular and genetic alterations thought to be involved in this process are largely unstudied. 

 

The objectives of this study were to evaluate the effects of nutrients on the progression of all stages of ovarian and peritoneal cancer and to explore the interactions between nutrients and the intrinsic host susceptibility in order to better understand nutritional and molecular mechanisms for the progression of these cancers.  Several public service announcements were made on television, radio and the print media, especially local newspapers covering West Los Angeles, South Los Angeles, and the San Fernando Valley areas.  Flyers and pamphlets describing the study were distributed widely in the UCLA community, the Medical Center and mailed to numerous cancer support groups.

 

Over 100 patients were fully screened and identified as potential candidates for entry on to this protocol.  This screening process netted 21 subjects who were randomized into the phase III study. Patients who had been entered onto the trial were carefully monitored, and serial blood samples were drawn and stored for analysis, as per the protocol.  Toward the end of the second year of funding, we were notified that we would not receive a thrid year of funding.  By the close of accrual to the study (7/15/02), 7 patients dropped out because of progressive disease and/or too ill to return to follow-up.  One additional patient dropped out because she wanted to be in the intervention group.  Thirteen subjects completed the full follow-up and close-out visits through the end of the trial grant period (7/1/02-10/31/02). 

 

Blood samples are currently being assayed for the parameters as outlined in the study, and we anticipate that the full analysis will be published. Serum samples from 13 patients in women undergoing dietary intervention was added to ovarian cancer cell lines in vitro in another series of experiments. This same procedure has been used to screen a wide variety of cell lines in vitro to assess potential growth differences caused by the use of serum from the same patient before and after the commencement of a diet very low in fat, high in fiber and supplemented with soy protein and extra fruits and vegetable.  The results of these experiments are pending. The study demonstrated the extraordinary difficulty in accruing patients to a randomized trial of dietary intervention in women with ovarian and peritoneal cancer, with a ratio of potentially eligible and interviewed patients to accrued and enrolled patients of about 20%.  The most common reason for non-accrual was the patient refusal because of the randomization, inaccessibility secondary to geographic considerations, and a very low-fat intake diet.

 

 

 

 

 

Exercise and Androgen Ablation in Prostate Cancer

Rowan T. Chlebowski, M.D., Ph.D.

Harbor-UCLA Research & Education Institute

$186,488.00 / 24 months

Prostate Cancer

Pilot and Feasibility Study Award

 

An increasing number of studies have suggested an inverse association of physical activity on prostate cancer.  In addition, androgen ablation, a mainstay of prostate cancer patient management had been implicated as potentially mediating life threatening conditions including osteoporosis fractures, coronary heart disease and diabetes.  Since in other populations physical activity has been associated with decreased diabetic complications and improvement in coronary heart disease risk factors we hypothesize that a supervised exercise program could be beneficial in prostate cancer patients by mitigating co-morbid conditions and directly influencing prostate cancer. 

 

To assess the feasibility of evaluating the hypothesis that exercise could successfully reduce co-morbidities expected with androgen ablation a pilot study involving patients with diagnosed prostate cancer without widespread metastases was conducted.  Ten patients (five with androgen ablative therapy and five without androgen ablation) were randomized in an exercise group and ten patients (four with androgen ablative therapy and six without androgen ablation) in a control group not offered an exercise program.  Baseline assessment identified individuals without androgen ablation as having normal testosterone levels compared to the extremely low testosterone levels seen in those with androgen ablation.  The exercise program involved thirty minutes of supervised exercise three times per week under the direction of an exercise physiologist performed at the clinic site.  At baseline, lipid profile, blood pressure, body composition, glucose tolerance and insulin levels, PSA, and muscle strength were evaluated.  These parameters were scheduled to be reevaluated after completion of the rigorous exercise program.  All participants randomized to the no-exercise program returned for their second evaluation visit.  Unfortunately, 60% of the participants randomized to the exercise program failed to complete their program.  Most withdrew after experiencing a limited number of sessions precluding any definitive determination of the effects of a program pf rigorous exercise on study parameters.  Attempts at further recruitment identified resistance in the participant burden involved in the exercise program (travel to the exercise facility and the physical effort required).  We conclude that a rigorous supervised exercise program performed at a central location may not be feasible for a population of elderly prostate cancer patients recruited from the general population.  If the exercise hypothesis is to be tested a more moderate program of exercise perhaps implemented in the local community setting or a more rigorous evaluation of potential participant’s interest in completing such a program (perhaps by use of a run-in) will be required.

 

 

 

 

Screening Telomerase for Prostate Cancer Detection

Laura E. Crocitto, M.D.

City of Hope National Medical Center

$213,750.00 / 24 months

Prostate Cancer

Pilot and Feasibility Study Award

 

Prostate Cancer is a leading cause of death in American males today. Screening for prostate cancer has been hotly debated from a cost-benefit standpoint. The current method for screening involves the use of physical exam and serum Prostate Specific Antigen (PSA) measurement. Both of these modalities are insensitive and lack the specificity for the optimal detection of early stage prostate cancer. The identification of new markers for the detection of this disease is greatly needed.

 

One candidate marker, which has recently been identified, is the human telomerase enzyme and its various components. Telomeres are structures found on the ends of human chromosomes. Chromosomes are those structures inside our cells, which contain genetic information. Telomeres are necessary for cells to divide normally. Part of the telomere is lost each time the cell divides until eventually the telomere is so short that it can no longer function properly. At this point the cell dies. Cancer cells have found a way to prevent loss of the telomeres. They produce an enzyme (protein) which is called telomerase. This enzyme allows cancer cells to continue to divide unchecked.

 

Telomerase activity has been identified in approximately 90% of prostate cancers. Recently, telomerase activity was also found to be present in the Expressed Prostatic Secretions (EPS) of patients with prostate cancer. In addition, high levels of expression of the components of the telomerase enzyme complex can serve as a marker of telomerase activity and thus, tumor detection. Our pilot project is aimed at identifying the most sensitive and specific methods for detecting telomerase activity and its components in the EPS of men undergoing evaluation for the diagnosis of prostate cancer. Since the pilot study began, we have established a method for EPS collection, and evaluated 30 EPS samples. In patients with prostate cancer, hTR detected 2/12 for a sensitivity of 16% and specificity of 93%. hTERT detected 6/6 prostate tumors for a sensitivity of 100% and specificity of 57% and TRAP detected 0/5 prostate tumors.

 

The detection of hTERT by RT-PCR appears to be a promising new method for the detection of prostate cancer in EPS.

 

 

1.       Crocitto LE, Korns D, Kretzner L, Shevchuk T, Blair SL, Wilson TG, Ramin SA, Kawachi MH, Smith SS. Prostate cancer molecular markers GSTP1 and hTERT in expressed prostatic secretions as predictors of biopsy results. Urology. 2004 Oct;64(4):821-5.

 

2.       Fuller RA, Clark J, Kretzner L, Korns D, Blair SL, Crocitto LE, Smith SS. Use of microfluidics chips for the detection of human telomerase RNA. Anal Biochem. 2003 Feb 15;313(2):331-4.

 

 

 

 

 

Morphologic Changes to the Sentinel Nodes in Melanoma: A Novel Mechanism for the Development and Treatment of Metastases

Richard Essner, M.D.

John Wayne Cancer Institute

$269,040.00 / 24 months

Skin Cancer

Pilot and Feasibility Study Award

 

Malignant melanoma once considered a rare disease now represents 4% of all cancers in the United States, its incidence is increasing faster than all other cancers except for lung cancer in women.  Melanoma is the 7th most common cancer in California with estimated 5,300 new cases in the year 2002, resulting in 900 deaths.  While melanoma is preventable by avoiding excessive sunlight exposure, public education in California has yet to have an impact on the alarming increasing rate of new cases.  Fortunately, most patients with melanoma are cured by excision of the primary skin cancer alone.  The most common route of spread of the disease is via direct passage of the melanoma from the skin to the adjacent lymph node basin and to other organ sites.  Over the last 100 years there has been debate among surgeons as to the treatment of melanoma when it appears localized to the skin.  Some surgeons recommend removal of the melanoma alone while others believe that removal of the adjacent lymph nodes can diminish the spread of melanoma and prevent deaths.  Yet surgical removal of normal-appearing lymph nodes is costly and can cause injury and rare death.  Several large clinical studies have addressed the role of excision of the regional lymph nodes.  While none of these studies have shown a survival benefit of this operative procedure each of the studies provide some suggestion that removal of normal-appearing lymph nodes early in the natural history of melanoma can help selected patients.

 

In the early 1990s investigators at the John Wayne Cancer Institute (Santa Monica) devised an alternative approach to the management of the regional lymph nodes in melanoma. 

 

Intraoperative lymphatic mapping and sentinel lymphadenectomy (LM/SL) was devised as a minimally invasive alternative to the traditional approaches to the regional lymph nodes.  LM/SL was based on the observations that lymphatic vessels leading from the skin to the regional lymph nodes can be mapped and the first lymph nodes (sentinel node, SN) could be identified and separated from the adjacent secondary (non-sentinel, non-SN) lymph nodes.  This procedure allows surgeons to determine the presence or absence of melanoma cells in SN without performing a complete lymph node dissection to discover cancer deposits.

 

In the past ten years considerable scientific effort has focused on the immunology of cancer and in particular on the creation of immune based therapies for melanoma.  The rationale for immunotherapy is based on understanding of the interaction of melanoma and the inherent immune function of the individual.  With increasing understanding of the immune system scientists have discovered a population of white blood cells critical for recognition and response to cancer.  Dendritic cells are the most potent of the antigen presenting cells yet represent only a very small fraction of the white blood cell population.  Dendritic cells are found throughout the blood stream, lymph nodes, and skin. 

 

Our investigations are a result of the unique opportunity that has arisen from the development of LM/SL.  We have found that both the physical appearance and function of dendritic cells in SN are altered in patients with melanoma, and this is related to the growth and increasing patient age.  We continue to investigate these changes to SN and methods to reverse the immune dysfunction.  We suspect these findings may be relevant to both the growth of the original skin cancer, but potentially also the pattern of spread of melanoma from the skin to lymph nodes and other sites. 

 

 

1.       Essner R, Lee JH, Wanek LA, Itakura H, Morton DL. Contemporary surgical treatment of advanced-stage melanoma. Arch Surg. 2004 Sep;139(9):961-6; discussion 966-7.

 

2.       Essner R, Chung MH, Bleicher R, Hsueh E, Wanek L, Morton DL. Prognostic implications of thick (>or=4-mm) melanoma in the era of intraoperative lymphatic mapping and sentinel lymphadenectomy. Ann Surg Oncol. 2002 Oct;9(8):754-61.

 

3.       Essner R and Cochran AJ. Sentinel node biopsy: not only a staging tool? Recent Results Cancer Res. 2002. 160: p. 133-48.

 

4.       Essner R, Kojima M. Dendritic cell function in sentinel nodes. Oncology (Huntingt). 2002 Jan;16(1 Suppl 1):27-31.

 

5.       Essner R, Kojima M. Surgical and molecular approaches to the sentinel lymph nodes. Ann Surg Oncol. 2001 Oct;8(9 Suppl):31S-34S.

 

 

 

 

 

Biomarker Angiogenesis Index Stratifies Metastatic Risk

John P. Fruehauf, M.D., Ph.D.

Oncotech, Inc.

$94,887.82 / 12 months

Prostate Cancer

Small Business Collaboration Award - Phase I

 

Prostate cancer is the leading cause of cancer in men, and the second leading cause of cancer death for men.  However, many men may be found to have prostate cancer at an early stage when it is still confined to the prostate, making it possible to potentially cure these men by surgical removal of the prostate and tumor. What is not clear is how to identify those men with disease apparently confined to the prostate who have actually had undetectable microscopic spread of the cancer out of the prostate. Cancer cells can escape the prostate in three ways.  They can grow through the prostate capsule into adjacent structures, which can be identified by the pathologist.  However, if the cells escape through the lymph system circulation, or through the blood stream, this cannot be detected by routine pathology tests. One way to determine if prostate cancer has spread is to perform bone scans and CT scans to identify sites of metastasis.  Unfortunately, these techniques are not sensitive enough to accurately identify patients with very small, but clinically significant, numbers of cells that have escaped. For men who have undergone “curative” radical prostatectomy, within 10 years approximately 10% of these men will have died of metastatic prostate cancer that was undetected initially.   These patients might benefit from a better method of predicting if cells have escaped.  Such a method would help the physician caring for these patients to offer additional therapy, such as hormone therapy, immediately after surgery rather than waiting until after the disease has recurred.  On the other hand, men who have a low risk of cancer spread could safely avoid therapy, and so avoid the associated side effects. Our study was directed toward the validation of a biomarker profile that can distinguish between aggressive carcinomas of the prostate that are likely to have spread versus those that are unlikely to have spread. The biomarker profile is based on the pivotal roles of tissue invasion and an increased number of small blood vessels that grow into more aggressive prostate cancers. Our group has developed an innovative numerical scale of molecular and pathological events called the angiogenesis index (AI) that appears to be significantly associated with prediction of progression of prostate cancer from a non-invasive state into an aggressive carcinoma that is likely to have spread even though on gross examination by the pathologist the tumor appears to be confined to the prostate. This index of early detection should accurately stratify patients with prostate carcinoma into low versus high metastatic risk groups. In our training sets, both invasion beyond the prostate to the seminal vesicles and the angiogenesis index were significantly associated with an increased relative risk of death after adjustment for tumor stage and grade. We have validated our methods and correlated our IHC procedures with outcomes for 100 cases of primary prostate carcinoma divided between low and high-grade tumors. Rigorous controls were employed to ensure that biomarker tissue measurements were highly reproducible and accurate. The study we performed that was funded by the CRP helped us to further validate the angiogenesis index so that it can be offered as a routine clinical test to prostate cancer patients. Urologists are now utilizing these biomarkers to help them improve their detection of aggressive disease and stratify patients for more appropriate treatment planning.  We believe that this newly validated testing can help doctors spare patients who have low risk disease from taking unnecessary therapy, while increasing the odds that patients with more aggressive prostate cancer will  aggressive therapy. In this way the angiogenesis index that was developed in part through the support provided by this grant can allow the treating physician to tailor therapy to the individual patient's unique tumor biology.

 

 

 

 

 

HPV Infection and Cervical Cancer Screening in Hispanics

Catherine Ley, Ph.D.

Stanford University

$296,789.00 / 36 months

Cervical Cancer

New Investigator Award

 

No final report submitted.

 

 

 

 

 

Rituximab in the Treatment of Primary CNS Lymphoma

James L. Rubenstein, M.D., Ph.D.

University of California, San Francisco

$306,279.96 / 36 months

CNS Lymphoma

Clinical Scientist Development Award

 

 No final report submitted.

 

1.       Rubenstein, J.L, Fischbein, N., Aldape, K., Burton, E., and Shuman, M. Hemorrhage and VEGF Expression in a Case of Primary Central Nervous System Lymphoma: Role of Vascular Endothelial Growth Factor.  J. Neuro-Oncology  2002. 58(1)  53-56.

2.       Rubenstein JL, Combs D, Rosenberg J, Levy A, McDermott M, Damon L, Ignoffo R, Aldape K, Shen A, Lee D, Grillo-Lopez A, and Shuman MA. Rituximab therapy for CNS lymphomas: targeting the leptomeningeal compartment. Blood. 2003. 101(2): p. 466-468.

 

 

Book Chapters

 

1. Pathophysiology of Disease: An Introduction to Clinical Medicine, 4th ed.  Neoplasia. Tripathy, D and Rubenstein, J.L.  [edited by] Stephen J. McPhee, Vishwanath R. Lingappa, William F. Ganong. New York : Lange Medical Books/McGraw-Hill, Medical Pub. Division, 2003. 760 pp

 

2.   Brain Metastases from Genito-Urinary Cancer: Germ Cell, Testicular, Prostate and Bladder Cancer  Theodosopoulos, P., Rubenstein, J. and McDermott in Brain Tumors Spetzler, R..  In Press.

 

 

 

 

 

PET Imaging for Prostate Cancer

Marc A. Seltzer, M.D.

University of California, Los Angeles

$307,326.40 / 36 months

Prostate Cancer

Clinical Scientist Development Award

 

Positron emission tomography (PET) is a non-invasive whole body imaging test that produces images that show body function, such as glucose metabolism of tumors.  Using this technique together with a positron emitting radioactive tracer, one can image tumor metabolism in patients with cancer. Two radioactive tracers of metabolism that can be imaged with PET are [F-18] fluorodeoxyglucose (FDG) which is a marker of glucose metabolism and C-11 acetate which is an intermediary probe of cellular lipid metabolism. Both tracers have shown promise in preliminary studies in prostate cancer.  The purpose of this project was to evaluate the performance of PET metabolic imaging for determining the presence and extent of disease in patients with prostate cancer.  Our study population comprised patients with newly diagnosed prostate cancer as well as patients with recurrent cancer suspected by a rising serum PSA level following local treatment such as radical prostatectomy or radiation therapy.  The ability of PET to more accurately determine the extent of disease could potentially result in more appropriate treatment strategies for the majority of prostate cancer patients.

 

During the past three years, we have achieved a better understanding of the role of PET imaging using C-11 acetate and FDG-PET in the diagnosis and staging of prostate.  We performed C-11 acetate and FDG-PET scans in patients with locally advanced primary prostate cancer and compared the imaging results from cancer patients to those obtained in a group of healthy normal volunteers.  We found that both FDG and C-11 acetate PET scans were unable to reliably differentiate benign from malignant prostate tissue.   We concluded that neither FDG nor C-11 acetate could be used for determining the presence and extent of tumor within the prostate gland.

 

We did, however, observe that both FDG and C-11 acetate PET can be succesfully used as a problem solving tool to determine the presence and extent of distant sites of prostate cancer spread (metastases) in patients who have failed prior local therapy with radical prostatectomy or radiation therapy.  Combined PET imaging using both FDG and C-11 acetate demonstrated evidence of metastatic disease in over 40% of patients with suspected tumor recurrence based on a high level of serum PSA or a rapid rate of rise in the level of the serum PSA.   In a significant number of patients, PET scans detected unsuspected sites of metastases that were either not seen or were poorly visualized by conventional imaging tests such as bone scan and computed tomography.  In a direct comparison of C-11 acetate PET to FDG-PET, C-11 acetate appeared to be a more sensitive and specific test than FDG-PET. Our relatively small patient sample size did not allow us to make a definitive conclusion as to whether C-11 acetate PET is a more reliable test than FDG-PET for detecting prostate cancer metastases.

 

We used PET scanning to quantify the metabolic activity of prostate malignancies and found that some tumors prefer C-11 acetate over FDG as a fuel for their metabolism.  This confirmed the results of prior in-vitro studies demonstrating that some neoplasms prefer the lipid metabolic pathway over the glucose metabolic pathway.  Interestingly, in a subset of patients with advanced metastatic prostate cancer that was unresponsive to systemic hormonal therapy, we found a majority of tumors appeared to have a higher rate of glucose utilization (as measured by FDG-PET) compared to lipid metabolism (as measured by C-11 acetate PET).

 

 

1.       Seltzer MA, Strum SB, Scholz, MC, Belldegrun A, Satyamurthy N, Bobinski KP, Phelps ME, Czernin J.  Comparison of whole body 11C Acetate and FDG PET in patients with prostate cancer.  Journal of Nuclear Medicine  2000; 41:142P.    

 

2.       Seltzer MA, Sparks R, Stout DB, Satyamurthy N, Dahlbom M, Phelps ME, Barrio JR.  Radiation Dose Estimates for 11C-Acetate Whole Body PET Imaging.  Journal of Nuclear Medicine  2001; 42:242P

 

3.       Seltzer MA, Jahan SA, Dahlbom M, Stout, DB, Satyamurthy N, Phelps ME, Barrio, JR, Czernin, J.  11C- Acetate PET Imaging of primaryand recurrent prostate cancer: comparison to normal controls.  Journal of Nuclear Medicine  2002; 43:117P

 

4.       Seltzer MA, Jahan SA, Dahlbom M, Satyamurthy N, Barrio JR, Phelps ME, Czernin J.  Combined metabolic imaging using C-11 acetate and FDG PET for the evaluation of patients with suspected recurrent prostate cancer. Journal of Nuclear Medicine  2003; 44(5 Supplement):132P.

 

5.       Seltzer M A, Jahan SA, Sparks R, Stout DB, Satyamurthy N, Dahlbom M, Phelps ME, Barrio JR. Human radiation dose estimates for C-11 acetate whole body PET.  Journal of Nuclear Medicine 2003; 44(5 Supplement):102P.

 

 

 

 

 

Evaluation of MN/CA9 Protein Expression in ASCUS Pap Smears as a Diagnostic Biomarker of Cervical Dysplasia/Neoplasia

Eric J. Stanbridge, Ph.D.

University of California, Irvine

$745,873.00 / 36 months

Cervical Cancer

Investigator-Initiated Award

 

Approximately 10% of all Pap smears are diagnosed as ASCUS.  Up to one third of patients receiving a Pap smear diagnosis of ASCUS will harbor a significant lesion, termed squamous intraepithelial lesion (SIL), and more rarely a carcinoma.

 

The major objective of this study is to provide an adjunct test to the conventional Papanicolaou (Pap) smear, that will allow for identification of those patients with a diagnosis of ASCUS who harbor a significant lesion (SIL and/or carcinoma).

 

We have identified a novel biomarker, the MN/CAIX protein, that detects early lesions of the cervix.  It is expressed by cells within the lesion but not the normal cervix.  We now wish to determine if it will aid in the diagnosis of cervical lesions of those women who repeatedly receive a Pap smear diagnosis of ASCUS. 

 

We have also tested the ASCUS-diagnosed Pap smears for the presence or absence of high risk human papillomavirus (HPV) types.

 

In our analysis we have screened both conventional Pap smears and a relatively new procedure of preparation, termed Thin Prep Pap smears.  In the conventional Pap smears, we observed that in those smears with a corresponding high grade lesion (CINII/III) in the tissue biopsy of the cervix we detected MN/CAIX- expressing atypical and normal cells in 100% of cases.  We also detected MN/CAIX expression of normal cells only in 50% of smears with a tissue biopsy that was diagnosed as benign, atypia or low grade lesion (CINI).  Thus, in conventional Pap smears we were able to detect all high grade lesions.  However, there is a high rate of false positives (approximately 50%).  Despite this, we conclude that MN/CAIX negative ASCUS-diagnosed conventional Pap smears indicate that the patient does not harbor a significant lesion.  This represents approximately 50% of all ASCUS-diagnosed women in this study.

 

Unfortunately, we encountered false negatives in the Thin Prep Pap smear study.  Our initial data suggest two reasons for this: the destruction of the MN/CAIX atigen with the fixation procedure used; and the relatively small number of cells, including atypical cells, in the Thin Prep smear. 

 

Our screening for high risk HPV types also indicated false negatives in those smears from patients harboring a significant lesion. 

 

Most recently, we have begun testing a new biomarker, p16, that looks promising but too few cases have been examined.

 

In conclusion, we believe it is likely that multiple biomarkers will be needed to adequately identify those ASCUS cases that harbor a significant lesion, with acceptable limits of sensitivity and specificity.          

     

1.       Cheng Y, Chakrabarti R, Garcia-Barcelo M, Ha TJ, Srivatsan ES, Stanbridge EJ, Lung ML. Mapping  of nasopharyngeal carcinoma tumor-suppressive activity to a 1.8-megabase region of chromosome band 11q13. Genes Chromosomes Cancer. 2002 May;34(1):97-103.

2.       Srivatsan ES, Chakrabarti R, Zainabadi K, Pack SD, Benyamini P, Mendonca MS, Yang PK, Kang K, Motamedi D, Sawicki MP, Zhuang Z, Jesudasan RA, Bengtsson U, Sun C, Roe BA, Stanbridge EJ, Wilczynski SP, Redpath JL. Localization of deletion to a 300 Kb interval of chromosome 11q13 in cervical cancer. Oncogene. 2002 Aug 15;21(36):5631-42.

3.       Kaluz S, Kaluzova M, Stanbridge EJ. Ezpression of the hypoxia marker carbonic anhydrase IX is critically dependent on SP1 activity. Identification of a novel type of hypoxia-responsive enhancer. Cancer Res. 2003 Mar 1;63(5):917-22.

4.      Kaluzova M, Kaluz S, Lerman MI, Stanbridge EJ. DNA damage is a prerequisite for p53-mediated proteasomal degradation of HIF-1alpha in hypoxic cells and downregulation of the hypoxia marker carbonic anhydrase IX. Mol Cell Biol. 2004 Jul;24(13):5757-66.

5.       Mendonca MS, Farrington DL, Mayhugh BM, Qin Y, Temples T, Comerford K, Chakrabarti R, Zainabadi K, Redpath JL, Stanbridge EJ, Srivatsan ES. Homozygous deletions within the 11q13 cervical cancer tumor-suppressor locus in radiation-induced, neoplastically transformed human hybrid cells. Genes Chromosomes Cancer. 2004 Apr;39(4):277-87.